The Supreme Court’s conservative majority has signaled it is poised to allow taxpayer-funded Catholic preschools to deny enrollment to children of same-sex couples. This potential ruling marks another significant legal victory for religious liberty advocates in education.
What Happened
During two hours of oral arguments, the conservative justices appeared unconvinced that Colorado’s universal preschool anti-discrimination law could override recent high-profile precedents expanding public funding access for religious schools.
Colorado’s 2020 universal preschool program provides state funding to both public and private schools. However, it requires participating institutions to comply with strict non-discrimination mandates regarding sexual orientation and gender identity.
The appeal, brought by the religious public interest firm Becket, challenges these provisions. The court's conservative wing questioned why the state implemented requirements that effectively exclude religious institutions.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned why Colorado "provoked" the clash instead of allowing Catholic schools an opt-out to respect religious rights. Meanwhile, Justice Amy Coney Barrett questioned whether the state used anti-discrimination rules as a pretext to push out religious participants.
Why It Matters
The case highlights an ongoing constitutional collision between First Amendment religious protections and state-level anti-discrimination laws designed to protect LGBTQ Americans. In recent years, the Supreme Court’s conservative majority has consistently favored religious claims in similar legal battles.
The court's liberal justices pushed back hard during arguments. Justice Sonia Sotomayor argued that allowing schools to exclude children based on parental sexual orientation permits discrimination under the guise of religious exercise.
Justice Elena Kagan warned about the broader implications. She noted that a ruling against Colorado could pave the way for numerous future claims where individuals argue that exposure to peers with different backgrounds or identities burdens their religious beliefs.
What's Next
A final ruling in the Colorado dispute is expected by the end of June. If the conservative majority rules in favor of the Catholic preschools, states nationwide may face new limitations when attempting to enforce anti-discrimination mandates on religious institutions receiving public funds.


