Netflix has a massive new global hit on its hands, but it is causing a sharp divide between professional reviewers and everyday streaming fans.
The maritime mystery series “Below” has taken over streaming charts worldwide since dropping on October 8. According to data from Flixpatrol, the show hit number one in 70 countries just one day after its release, surging to 83 countries by day two. In Germany and dozens of other regions, it remains firmly at the top of the charts.
A Record-Breaking Launch for Netflix
The impressive run goes beyond mere chart positions. Entertainment trade publication Deadline reports that the series pulled in 17 million views during its opening weekend alone.
This milestone makes "Below" the most successful debut ever for a Canadian Netflix production, signaling a major win for the platform's regional content strategy in North America.
Set in a remote coastal town in Newfoundland, the plot follows a protective local fisherman grappling with an old family tragedy decades after his father's mysterious death. When a dangerous sea creature surfaces near the island, he teams up with a marine expert to protect his family and uncover dark secrets lurking in the community's past.
Critics Love It, But Fans Are Hesitant
Despite its massive streaming numbers, audience reception tells a different story.
On Rotten Tomatoes, "Below" boasts a strong 87% approval rating from professional critics, who have praised its moody cinematography and deliberate pacing. However, everyday viewers are far more reserved. The audience score sits at a mediocre 55%, mirroring lukewarm reactions on social media and platforms like Letterboxd, where it averages 3.1 out of 5 stars.
Why It Matters: The Regional Content Dilemma
This widening gap between critical acclaim and audience satisfaction highlights a recurring challenge for major streaming services. As platforms pour heavy marketing budgets into regional hubs outside of Hollywood—such as Canada, Scandinavia, and South Korea—high-concept hooks often draw massive initial viewership.
However, when atmospheric storytelling prioritizes slow-burn dread over rapid plot progression, casual viewers accustomed to fast-paced algorithmic hits can quickly grow impatient. For Netflix, the strong opening weekend proves the commercial viability of Canadian regional mysteries, even if viewer retention remains a hurdle for future episodes.
Future Outlook
With "Below" currently holding strong at the top of international charts, all eyes are on Netflix to see whether the platform greenlights a second season. Given the record-breaking viewership numbers, a renewal is mathematically likely, though showrunners will likely need to address viewer feedback regarding pacing if they want to close the satisfaction gap in a potential sophomore run.

