Sports

Why Islam Makhachev's UFC Title Hold-Up Is Sparking Debate

Islam Makhachev balked at a UFC 336 title defense against Carlos Prates, triggering division-wide drama and a defense from Daniel Cormier.

WhyThisBuzz DeskFeb 19, 20252 min read
Share:

What Happened

The MMA world is buzzing after reigning welterweight champion Islam Makhachev pulled back from negotiations for a UFC 336 title defense against rising contender Carlos Prates. Initially slated for a January 30 card in Toronto, Makhachev pumped the brakes, suggesting that Prates and Michael Morales should hash out the No. 1 contender spot inside the Octagon instead of jumping straight into a title fight.

Makhachev also dropped hints about retirement, signaling he may be nearing the final chapter of his career. The hesitation didn't sit well with UFC boss Dana White or Prates himself, who quickly accused the champion of stalling and actively avoiding a matchup.

Why It Matters

Accusations of ducking contenders can quickly sour a champion's reputation, especially in a stacked 170-pound division. Prates believes he earned his shot, while critics argue that elite titleholders should take on all comers without delay.

However, former two-division champion Daniel Cormier has rushed to Makhachev's defense. Dismissing the narrative that the Dagestani fighter is scared, Cormier argued that Makhachev’s scheduling approach mirrors most long-reigning champions who carefully weigh the high stakes of every defense rather than fighting constantly like Merab Dvalishvili.

Important Context

Timing is also playing a massive role in the division's current gridlock. With Ramadan approaching on February 8, Makhachev will observe the month-long fast, pushing any potential Octagon return to mid-2027.

Cormier emphasized that while Prates' frustration is valid, the Brazilian needs to refocus. Before any talk of a championship belt can resume, Prates must first get past a dangerous test against Michael Morales.

What's Next

The path forward for the welterweight division hinges entirely on upcoming matchmaking. Prates has a clear directive if he wants to secure his championship aspirations: silence the noise, handle the Morales threat, and prove he deserves the next shot at gold when the division's timeline clears up.