Sports

The Real Reason Behind Unexpected NHL Playoff Seeding

When NHL teams finish tied on points, total wins aren't what split them. Here is how the overlooked Regulation Wins column dictates the Stanley Cup playoff picture.

WhyThisBuzz DeskNov 15, 20262 min read
Share:

Every spring, hockey fans glance at the NHL standings expecting simple math. But when two teams finish level on points, total wins alone will not determine who claims home-ice advantage in the postseason.

Instead, the playoff picture comes down to a small, frequently skipped stat: RW (Regulation Wins).

The Hidden Tiebreaker

When two clubs end the regular season tied in points, the NHL works through a strict tiebreaker hierarchy. Since 2019, regulation victories—games won inside 60 minutes—hold top priority.

The impact showed up clearly in the 2025-26 season:

  • Montreal vs. Tampa Bay: Both finished with 106 points, but Tampa Bay earned home ice because they accumulated more regulation wins.
  • Philadelphia vs. Carolina: Tied at 99 points, Philadelphia lost the tiebreak despite earning 43 total victories. A massive 16 of those wins came in extra time or shootouts, inflating their overall points while weakening their tiebreaker standing.

Games decided in 60 minutes award two points total, whereas any game extending into overtime distributes three points across both teams. Over an 82-game schedule, those extra overtime points often mask underlying 5-on-5 flaws.

Why the System Changed

The league has spent two decades tweaking extra-time rules to reward teams that finish games early.

The evolution followed a clear path:

  • 1999–2000: Introduced the single point for overtime losses to prevent cautious play.
  • 2005–06: Added shootouts to eliminate ties completely.
  • 2010–11: Created ROW (Regulation + Overtime Wins) to strip shootout wins from the top tiebreaker spot.
  • 2019–20: Promoted RW ahead of ROW, prioritizing regulation dominance over 3-on-3 overtime or shootout gimmicks.

Nearly a quarter of all NHL games now extend past regulation. In 2025-26 alone, 326 games went to extra time, yielding 119 shootouts. Clubs like the Los Angeles Kings went past 60 minutes in 33 of their 82 contests—nearly two out of every five nights.

What to Watch Next

The math grows even more critical as the league moves into an 84-game regular-season schedule—the first 84-game slate since 1993-94.

With 1,344 total regular-season matchups across the league, the added calendar games will create even more three-point scenarios. Teams that control 60 minutes of action, like Colorado's league-leading 48 regulation wins in 2025-26, hold a distinct edge over clubs relying on extra-time magic.

When scanning the standings for true contenders, skip the points column and look at the RW tally instead.