In a significant legal setback for federal prosecutors, a magistrate judge has thrown out criminal charges against two former FBI officials accused of lying to Congress about the Hunter Biden laptop investigation. The court's sharp rebuke highlighted critical errors in the prosecution's case and questioned the timing of the filing.
What Happened
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed the criminal complaint against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides on Monday. The judge ruled that prosecutors failed to establish probable cause showing the defendants knowingly made false statements.
The Justice Department charged Floris and Benavides last month, alleging they lied during 2023 testimony before the House Judiciary Committee. Both officials previously served on an FBI foreign influence task force formed after the 2016 election.
Leading up to the 2020 election, their task force raised concerns that Russian intelligence might launch a disinformation campaign involving Hunter Biden's laptop to influence the presidential race.
The Judge’s Scathing Ruling
Judge Faruqui offered a stern critique of the government's handling of the case, concluding that some statements cited by prosecutors were not actually false, while others stemmed from "honest mistakes of memory."
The judge also directly addressed the political backdrop, pointing out that charges were brought just 10 days before the upcoming midterm elections.
"What has transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization," Faruqui declared in court, stating he would not "pretend I cannot read a calendar." He reprimanded prosecutors for rushing the indictment and making fundamental errors.
Important Context
The investigation into the two former officials gained momentum following a July presidential address on election security. Shortly after, FBI Director Kash Patel ordered the bureau's Kansas City field office to scrutinize Floris. She had previously disputed an intelligence report concerning Chinese interference in the 2020 election.
The case comes amid heightened attention on Justice Department prosecutions targeting individuals involved in high-profile political investigations.
What's Next
Although the initial complaint has been dismissed, the legal saga might not be completely finished. Federal prosecutors still have the option to seek a formal indictment by presenting their evidence to a grand jury. However, Judge Faruqui's ruling places a heavy burden of proof on the government moving forward.



